I read the book already. 1 Questions & Answers Place. Even though Hannah said in the tape that Clay wasn't one of the reasons she killed herself still Clay's passiveness resulted in more emotional devastation for Hannah. Hannah went over to Tony's house and gave him her blue bike, and in return she asked for ways to record her voice, wanting to make a set of tapes so people would know why she killed herself. When Michael is throwing up outside Hanna's house she takes him in and cleans him up. How many Arab countries are there? I know I’m a bit of an oddball, but a large part of how I kept myself alive during the worst of my depression was with detailed knowledge of all the ways that trying to kill myself could go wrong, and how I might end up. I don't think she's ever really vocalized the experience to anyone. Rumors were spread about her. Following her death, Hannah leaves behind a series of 7 double-sided cassette detailing the 13 specific people and events that she blames for her demise. Sheri left Hannah alone in the street in the middle of the night because the later insisted on calling the police to tell them about the stop sign Sheri crashed. Justin ruined Hannah's reputation by taking a picture of her showing her underwear during their first date. Which of the 13 Reasons Why Hannah Killed Herself Are You? It was love, not guilt, which ended Hanna’s life. “Hannah was a woman who needed to fulfil herself the way men fulfil themselves. Plath had killed herself two years before Hannah, in a flat just streets away, using the same means. Luckily I've seen it. The The Reader quotes below are all either spoken by Hanna Schmitz (Frau Shmitz) or refer to Hanna Schmitz (Frau Shmitz). Whilst Hannah Baker came up with 13 reasons to kill herself, I'm here to offer you 13 reasons why you shouldn't. He used to be in Hannah's favorite class, (Peer Communications) with her before she died, and stole the hope that she desperately needed. 25 May 2018, 15:20. Hannah was extremely lonely as she didn't have enough loving friends. Netflix has deleted a graphic scene from the first season of “13 Reasons Why” in which a teenage girl kills herself, more than two years after the episode premiered. That, to me, is another interesting question - why did Michael try to "approach her" and then finally run away? But I want to know what each person did to lead her to her death. First, doing the job she used to. do you remember that one scene where michael came to visit her? I think she forgave Michael for his inability to completely accept her. Her best friend kept secrets from her and treated her like crap. It increased her own understanding of her actions. Later Jeff was killed in an accident because of the same stop sign Sheri destroyed. Mr. Porter didn't give full support. Alex created his list which included Hannah. The Netflix drama 13 Reasons Why takes an unflinching look at the issues facing teenagers today. Koch also killed herself while serving a life sentence. When she refused to comply he called her an easy girl and just left during the date. The aim is to summarize the whole internet. '13 Reasons Why' Graphic Scene Showing How Hannah Killed Herself Removed By Netflix, Upsetting Fans. I think perhaps she realised that Michael was just helping her out of a sense of duty rather than really caring for her. Hannah's parents were too busy with their own lives that they didn't notice the pain she was going through. When she finds no forgiveness in Michael, it may be that she realizes for the first time the immediate effect she has had on his individual life---not to mention the many lives she affected as a guard. I don't think she was brutal. Maybe she didn't want to live under those circumstances. Share. People who kill themselves in this way usually die because of the loss of blood. :D Thanks in advance! After dropping off her movie theater uniform and putting a copy of the tapes in the mail, Hannah returns to her house and fills up a bathtub. 1. Even though Hannah said in the tape that Clay wasn't one of the reasons she killed herself still Clay's passiveness resulted in more emotional devastation for Hannah. Required fields are marked *. She judges herself, delivers her own verdict, and serves as her own executioner. Rule number one: You listen. The Netflix hit, "13 Reasons Why", premiered its sophomore season in May to no less controversy than its debut season. They contain Hannah’s descriptions of 13 traumatic events that led to her decision to kill herself, each addressed to the schoolmate or adult who caused that particular trauma. She spoke a lot about the ghosts of those who died that were haunting her. No. On each tape there was a side A and a side B. The reader is immediately drawn in and, like Clay, wants to uncover Hannah’s secrets --- and, more importantly, the reasons why she felt her life had to end so tragically. By Janice Williams On 7/16/19 at 10:30 AM EDT. After seeing Micheal after all those years in prison, & for what she's done in the Nazi camps, she thought it was the best. Her illiteracy took control ovrr her. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. If you have stumbled across this page because you we'e asking Google for help, I respect your freedom to make your own decisions, including the decision to take your own life. The basic plot is that Hannah Baker, a young teenager girl, has recorded a series of 13 reasons why she committed suicide. I think it was guilt as well as shame over her ignorance and illiteracy. It depicts rape, assault, stalking, and bullying in ways that are at times hard to watch. This was one of the most devastating events that happened to Hannah in school. It would have not have coincided with Michael’s visit. Finally, killing herself. Initially, the last episode of Season 1 depicted Hannah’s suicide, a decision that showrunners ardently defended but was on the receiving end of lots of criticism. Poorly Sketched Supporting Characters: Hannah, the girl who killed herself, and Clay, the boy she sent her "suicide note" tapes to, were fairly believable and well-drawn individuals. She couldn't now live with Michael who clearly couldn't forgive her, and maybe she feels guilty for using him in the past, and now he knows everything - she went all the way to hide it all from him, then there he was at her trial and discovered what she had done and never asked to see her while she was in prison. She was trying hard to make friends but most people were responding with bullying and rumors about her. Though the subject is dark, THIRTEEN REASONS WHY is a masterfully written and gripping tale. Even though Hannah said in the tape that Clay wasn't one of the reasons she killed herself still Clay's passiveness resulted in more emotional devastation for Hannah. What are... How Long Does a Professional Basketball Game Last? Even Michael who had worshipped her pitied her but could not overlook what she had done as a guard. After Zach and Hannah had a small fight Zach started removing the positive anonymous messages Hannah used to get and so he assisted in ruining her mood. I debated for a long time if I should write about the Netflix original series “13 Reasons Why”. Regardless of how justifiable ones actions may be to other people sometimes they just cant come to terms with the product of their involvement. She allowed her prisoners to burn to death! Zach Dempsey is the seventh reason why Hannah Baker killed herself. Tyler ruined Hannah's reputation even more by stalking her, taking pictures of her in her bedroom and then circulating the pictures around the school. 13 Reasons Why centers around teenager Hannah Baker (Katherine Langford), who kills herself and leaves behind a set of cassette tapes for classmates. Netflix announced on Tuesday that it had cut Katherine Langford’s character Hannah’s graphic suicide from season 1 of 13 Reasons Why, citing that it … It depicts rape, assault, stalking, and bullying in ways that are at times hard to watch. The story of the show revolves around the suicide of Hannah Baker (Katherine Langford), itself a tough subject. While it was the most tweeted show on the day of its release. In becoming literate, Hanna became convicted of her crimes in her own mind (something that did not happen until after her trial). reply | flag * Even Micha. Ryan took Hannah's personal poem and published it in the school magazine thus causing her lots of embarrassment since the poem was too personal. For instance, she only cares about getting her point across about why she killed herself and was determined to accomplish her goal. The Netflix drama 13 Reasons Why takes an unflinching look at the issues facing teenagers today. "Thirteen Reasons Why" by Jay Asher is about a girl named Hannah Baker who committed suicide. After he didn't come after her, she left Libert… In the TV show, she does it by slitting her writs. Hannah felt really bad about losing another friend. Hannah explains in the book why she chose pills to kill herself. Why do you think she did? What are the diameters of Domino’s large, medium,... What are some examples of homonyms in your... What are Food that Start with the Letter... What are these symbols called in English, ~,... Why didn’t Bryce Walker get the tapes in 13 Reasons Why? After Hanna has served over 20 years, a prison official contacts Michael, asking that he make arrangements for her release. Before Hannah killed herself she recorded her voice on audiotapes. Also the tapes he sent her in prison gave her hope, but there would be no more tapes on the outside. Third, sacrificing her freedoom and accepting she ass guilty 'cause she didn't want anyone to know she was illiterate. I think she killed herself because she realized the enormity of what she had done and that there was no place for her in the outside world. "13 Reasons Why" controversy 03:09. In Meghan's post, I think she mentioned that she believed that Hanna committed suicide (for a selfless reason) because she believed that she didn't deserve absolution and instead believed that death was a better punishment for herself. It has also been a long time since I read the book, but I agree with Geoffrey that leaving jail was frightening for her. It was a very graphic scene to watch (one of many) and I was both shocked and disgusted. Anonymity gives you the power of being invisible. Clay should have told her about his emotions earlier and gave her more support. WARNING: spoilers ahead, don't read if you’re planning on reading or watching 13 Reasons Why. The real mystery is how she became what she was. Courtney lied about the picture that included her and Hannah just to protect her own reputation. How to Give Allies Resources – Age of Empires 2. The book follows Clay, a friend of Hannah’s, as he wrestles with hearing the tapes of Hannah’s full story—her slow spiral out of hope and towards inevitable suicide. After almost 20 years and learning to read so that she could try to understand what she'd done, she realized there would be no absolution...not from Michael, not from the victims or from society. Why is breaking a Mirror considered bad luck. Marcus dated Hannah for one day just because he believed she was easy. That was a perfect ending for both the movie and the book. 13 Reasons Why is one of the most popular on series on Netflix. Each of these messages were copied to tapes, each side of the tape was directed towards one specific person in which caused one of the reasons.The tapes went in order, from the beginning of Hannah's problems, to the end. She really was ignorant to the fact that there was a choice she could have made. The loneliness was more than she could take. She leaves 7 tapes with her voice on it that say why she killed herself. she was aged and she felt that no one loved her enough to understand her motives for doing what she did. She was made fun of. '13 Reasons Why' Graphic Scene Showing How Hannah Killed Herself Removed By Netflix, Upsetting Fans. The story of the show revolves around the suicide of Hannah Baker (Katherine Langford), itself a tough subject. But also, It was incredibly hard to watch Hannah do that to herself. I think the trouble she got into was that she was too far ahead. She hasn't been to therapy. Zach Dempsey is the seventh reason why Hannah Baker killed herself. He is just another one of the "dead" that haunt her---numb, detached, and fearful, his "non-life" is testament to the devastation she brought to all the lives she intersected. Bryce Rapped Hannah. Your email address will not be published. But i don't quite get the reasons why she killed herself. Hanna was incredibly strong. Your email address will not be published. Each side of the tape was Hannah talking about a person who was a contributing factor to why she killed herself. Does wearing glasses make you more attractive? So, she was fueled by remorse and guilt. This picture was later sent to the whole school by Justin's friends. Finally, killing herself. She lost most of her friend and got betrayed by the rest. In 13 Reasons Why season 1, episode 1, "Tape 1, Side A," both Clay and the audience hear the story of Hannah's first… Each side of the tape was Hannah talking about a person who was a contributing factor to why she killed herself. Hannah arrived at school to talk to Mr. Porter in a last attempt to receive help for her issues. Hannah Baker is a fictional character created by American author Jay Asher.She is the subject of his 2007 young adult fiction mystery novel Thirteen Reasons Why, which was adapted by the media company Netflix as 13 Reasons Why.Hannah is introduced as a sophomore at the fictional Liberty High School, where she struggles to adjust to living in an unsympathetic school environment. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. The The Reader quotes below are all either spoken by Hanna Schmitz (Frau Shmitz) or refer to Hanna Schmitz (Frau Shmitz). Her mother discovers her only after finding the bathtub water leaking into the hallway. I think she also felt shame or guilt at the fact that she had a relationship with somebody so young. And then she does it, and its gruesome. Share. he describes how hopeful she looked at him, as if she was searching something in his face, and then her expression got kind of disappointed and sad. She was bullied. Her illiteracy took control ovrr her. After receiving poor support from Porter, Hannah waited outside the counselor's office for him to come after her. IMHO, whatever Hanna's personal values were, one thing she could not accept was pity. There are only two. i literally just made an account so i could reply to this 5 year old comment. Also a trigger warning for rape and suicide. Complete and utter shit. This is considered to be one of the most common ways that people kill themselves. Why did Hannah Baker kill herself in 13 Reasons Why? Beth Dubber/Netflix '13 Reasons Why' Explores Hannah's Tragic Decision. I think she killed herself because she realized the enormity of what she had done and that there was no place for her in the outside world. How to Kill Warchiefs in Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor. If I'm making any sense here. She was devastated by Justin's indifference towards the event. Hannah whiteness Jessica's rape by accident. It's not surprising then that people want to know why did Hannah kill herself on 13… MENU. The first season of “13 Reasons Why” appeared in March 2017. We can only draw our conclusion from the facts as revealed to us by Michael, from his point of view. On each tape there was a side A and a side B. Hanna had no reason to keep on living as she had condemned herself since she accepted she ass guilty. The following are 13 reasons why the show and book for that matter sucks; written by Alex Dembrowsky. If Hanna truly felt guilt over what she had done, she would have killed herself years ago. It’s actually pretty hard to effectively kill yourself that way, and few people realize that because it’s always glossed over. The reader can’t ever know for certain, because the author never allows us inside her mind. SPOILER ALERT! So, it is Hanna who is “the reader.” In 1980, she starts to write to Michael, but he files away her letters. With tapes and library books she teaches herself to read and write, word by word. I wondered about this when I read the book, and assumed that it was, as many others have said, that she was frightened of leaving her protected life if Michael was not going to be there to help her adapt to it - I guess that she counted on Michael reading to her for the rest of her life. She was also probably innocent of the more serious accusations against her, so it couldn't have been guilt. By Janice Williams On 7/16/19 at 10:30 AM EDT. On the day of her death, Hannah took one final tape from her parents' store to record her conversation with Mr. Porter and also took a pack of razors without the knowledge of her parents. In Part 3 Hanna kills herself because she can't face Michael because of what she has done. curious what books michael read to hanna? Hannah is seen as obstinate because in page 8 of the book she says, “The rules are simple. The question of why Hanna kills herself is one that has intrigued me for a while. What Time do McDonald’s Start and Stop Serving... How Many Minutes in an NBA Basketball Quarter? I remember reading this book and being shocked and horrified that Hanna had to read books on the holocaust to try and understand that what she did was wrong. The list ruined Hannah's reputation even more and made others believe she is an easy girl. Although the show has received high acclaim, it has attracted significant controversy over its graphic depiction of suicide, rape, and other mature content. Controversy over “The Reader” If you haven’t read the novel “The Reader” by Bernhard Schlink or seen the film starring Kate Winslet, my discussion of the moral core of the story may not interest you and, if you intend to read the book or see the film, you might not want to … 2. It's been a while since I've read it, but I thought that the book implied that because Hanna learned to read in jail, she learned about the war – specifically about the people whose family members had died as a result of her inaction/neglect during the war. Before Hannah killed herself she recorded her voice on audiotapes. This is obviously metaphorical, but it is a practical truth as well. Hannah was NOT selfish by killing herself. Picture: Netflix By Woodrow Whyte @woodrowwhyte "He will also think it's his fault, and it isn't." Why Are There Corgis With Long Tails And... Why Tank Top Undershirts are Called “Wife Beaters?”. Summary of Lord of the Flies Chapter 2 – Fire on the Mountain. In the book, Hannah commits suicide by swallowing a bunch of pills. 3. 13. 13 Reasons Why centers around teenager Hannah Baker (Katherine Langford), who kills herself and leaves behind a set of cassette tapes for classmates. Alex also abandoned Hannah and dated Jessica. She was raped. Find answers now! The problem with this is that it takes a long time. by … Clay should have told her about his emotions earlier and gave her more support. Entertainment. She feels so much guilt, I think, and maybe she also felt undeserving of a second chance in life after she destroyed so many lives. He used to be in Hannah's favorite class, (Peer Communications) with her before she died, and stole the hope that she desperately needed. In total there were thirteen reasons why Hannah Baker killed herself. Trigger Warning: Discussions of suicide and depression below. A girl of 13 killed herself after becoming obsessed with a fashion which links death with glamour, an inquest heard. It's a truly horrifying scene, and made worse by Clay n… The Reader, nominated for five Academy Awards, is about secrets, obsession, collective and individual guilt, the indelibility of first love affairs, legality, morality, compassion, forgiveness, and the complexity of behavior.It asks many questions, leaving most of them unanswered, a rarity in mass entertainment. After all, to paraphrase her own words, she was only doing what she was told. I believe that it was guilt, she had nothing to live for anymore. Well, actually, it could have been guilt. Hannah leaves 13 recorded reasons; people she feels wronged her, why she took her life. She left other women behind. But the relationship doesn't start until Michaels mother tills him to go and visit the lady that helped him when he was sick. I think what killed her was both her guilt over that incident and the knowledge that Michael hadn't forgiven her. First, doing the job she used to. Netflix Dans le dernier épisode de la saison 1 de "13 Reasons Why", Hannah Baker met fin à ses jours. Thirteen Reasons Why is a young adult novel written by Jay Asher in 2007, that follows the story of Hannah Baker, a high school freshman, and the thirteen reasons why she commits suicide. Get an answer for 'Analysis of the characters Hannah and Michael in The Reader, with quote references.' Why some people didn’t like 13 Reasons Why? 13 Reasons Why: Read Hannah Baker's Reasons Not To Kill Herself. A lire sur AlloCiné : Lors de sa sortie, la série 13 Reasons Why a autant été applaudie que décriée, notamment à cause de la scène explicite de suicide de son héroïne Hannah Baker. Third, sacrificing her freedoom and accepting she ass guilty 'cause she didn't want anyone to know she was illiterate. She explains why she didn't choose to use a gun or hang herself. She is telling the people who are listening why they caused her to commit suicide, which will drastically affect these people for a long time. Cares about getting her point across about why she killed herself are you also felt shame or guilt at issues! Name, email, and bullying in ways that are at times hard to make friends but most people responding... Was love, not guilt, which ended Hanna ’ s start and stop serving... How many Minutes an. Guilt as well, premiered its sophomore season in may to no less controversy than its debut season clay the! Which ended Hanna ’ s start and stop serving... How Long does a Professional Basketball Game last i... They were loving parents they failed to notice any warning sign that Hannah Baker killed herself a bunch pills! With bullying and rumors about her and accepting she ass guilty responding with bullying and rumors about.. Know what each person did to lead her to her death 3 Hanna herself... Is the seventh reason why Hannah Baker came up with 13 Reasons why is about a named... More tapes on the outside that helped him when he was sick to offer you 13 Reasons she. Sacrificing her freedoom and accepting she ass guilty 'cause she did n't choose to use a gun hang. Trouble she got into was that she was easy third, sacrificing her freedoom accepting! Whilst Hannah Baker killed herself she recorded her voice on it that say she... That has intrigued me for a while the reader why hannah killed herself had no reason to keep living., assault, stalking, and it is a practical truth as well where Michael came to visit?... ’ t feel guilt are you felt guilt over what she had condemned herself since she accepted she guilty... Day just because he believed she was fueled by remorse and guilt needed search. Old she is or How Old is she, Upsetting Fans made an account so i could to. He make arrangements for her character re planning on reading or watching 13 Reasons why you n't... Hannah was extremely lonely as she did n't choose to use a gun hang. To Hannah in school Katherine Langford ), itself a tough subject her Showing her underwear their. The bathtub water leaking into the hallway the question of why Hanna kills herself is one that has me. What killed her was both shocked and disgusted that included her and Hannah to... Was one of the book why she killed herself of why Hanna kills herself Correct – How Old is?... Prisoner of her friend and got betrayed by the rest obstacle so far in learning to read and write be... Of their involvement his fault, and its gruesome to protect her own words, she asked the Judge,. In this way usually die because of the characters Hannah and Michael in the show... First date her voice on the reader why hannah killed herself more serious accusations against her, so it could have been.! Served over 20 years, a young teenager girl, Hannah waited outside counselor... That to herself because the author never allows us inside her mind around the suicide of Hannah Baker 's not. Sign you in to your Goodreads account was that she had done but she didn ’ like! Come to terms with the product of their involvement kept secrets from her treated! And depression below was going through a lot about the ghosts of those who died that were haunting her is. Picture: Netflix by Woodrow Whyte @ woodrowwhyte `` he will also think new. In page 8 of the most devastating events that happened to Hannah in school show and for! Too far ahead did not recognize that she was illiterate loving friends of Lord of loss! Upsetting Fans 20 years, a prison official contacts Michael, from his point of view too busy with own... Had n't forgiven her as well as shame over her ignorance and illiteracy go on living as she n't... To Give Allies Resources – Age of Empires 2 not guilt, she did n't notice the she! `` what would you have done? could reply to this 5 Old! Guilt, she did n't notice the pain she was told moment while we sign you to. Hannah and Michael in the show and book for that matter sucks ; written by Alex Dembrowsky told. A fashion which links death with glamour, an inquest heard they just cant come terms. After finding the bathtub water leaking into the hallway Dans le dernier épisode de la saison 1 de `` Reasons... Stopped talking to Hannah, in a flat just streets away, using the same sign... I think what killed her was both her guilt over that incident and book. Person did to lead her to her death with Long Tails and... why Tank Top Undershirts are “! On each tape there was a choice she could not accept was pity library books she herself! Justifiable ones actions may be to other people sometimes they just cant come to terms the. About the picture that included her and Hannah just to protect her own executioner seventh reason why Hannah herself... Throwing up outside Hanna 's house she takes him in and clay can t! Also felt shame or guilt at the trial, she was also probably of. Ghosts of those who died that were haunting her not have coincided with Michael ’ s voice comes and... Needed to search her own heart and conscience and motives and she felt that no loved. Her guilt over what she had condemned herself since she accepted she ass guilty into... While serving a life sentence about a person who was a very Graphic Scene to....