Just remember, anchovies are salty (about 117 milligrams of sodium in one fillet), so be judicious. I have a strong taste aversion towards fish/seafood, but that Futurama episode always makes me crave pizza with anchovies especially because, in my mind, they're just salty. Anchovy … Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I do and they go great with onions and mushrooms. Got a question about today’s news? Why are "ANCHOVIES" so salty ? I'm strangely disappointed, but I'm happy with your warning. I’m looking for a brand of canned anchovies that don’t taste like you’ve been tasered by a taser gun made out of salt. This is an extremely simplified but effective analogy for how difficult and seemingly impossible strong taste aversions are to overcome using basic logic. I ordered a half-anchovy pizza for myself for the first time just to experiment. Salt is commonly added when they are prepared for human consumption. Straight from the Elements of Cooking I learned that they need to be soaked in milk for thirty minutes to wash away all that salt. Anchovies ought to be savory, not aggressively salty. Not all anchovy are salty, not all anchovy are preserved or cured in salt. It also depends on the place. Another thing: Tradition dictates that the anchovies used on pizza should be rinsed of salt before baking. I’m not sure if this is completely normal, but mine came whole (though headless). I don't go anchovy every time, but like 1 out of 5 pizza orders i will. Fresh anchovies have a pretty short shelf life (like all seafood) so your best bet is to go to your local fishmonger and ask if they sell them. Setup pie like this and your good to go. Don’t let the bad-anchovies-on-pizza experience from years ago scare you from giving them another chance. Fish should make regular appearances in your diet, and eating at least 6 ounces of fish a week protects you from cardiovascular disease, explains the Harvard School of Public Health. Bulk anchovies … By salting them, it ensures that people can use them for flavor instead of the nearly non-existent meat. Pour milk or water over the anchovies. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. So do the long string of dinner guests to whom I've surreptitiously fed anchovies in various sauces, soups, salads, and stews. Anchovies are great, especially after a drink or two. Back when I was younger I ate some sort of fish (EDIT: So I ended up asking my mom about this incident. This is because strong brine is routinely used in the preservation process. That’s their function in life. It's meant to be used in cooking as topping on a pizza, to make sauce for pasta, or to make Caesar dressing. I'm not even going to give it a try. I like salty, but most canned anchovies are pretty bonkers on the salty flavor. 1 year ago. Anchovies are frequently purchased in cans or jars, which means they’re high in sodium. I get through a lot of good old basic sea salt, eat a fair bit of parmesan, love an olive or two but treat anchovies as medicine. Anchovies and black jelly beans. Before we go any further, let's get a few things straight. I'll be throwing up all over the table/pizza. On on hand, they make for a unique meat flavor. I still don’t like the smell of seafood cooking, but I can even eat with people that are all eating fish/seafood dishes. Anchovies are small, so there’s no much meat on them. During a recent short break to Spain with a couple of friends, one of the culinary delights we enjoyed was anchovies prepared in the Cantabrian style. The tinned grocery-store anchovies are usually packed in oil. Some anchovies are cured and packed in salt, and need to be soaked. It would be pretty inefficient to get a bunch of them together, debone them, and serve the meat. Edit 3: Thanks again for all the Advice ( and the hilarious jokes) and we all heard it a million times but can't believe that I got over 20k upvotes for a post like that. Nikki P. Lv 7. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. (They serve bright boquerones on toast with tomato and avocado, among other delights.) Why are "ANCHOVIES" so salty ? Ham, and … Anchovies, while perhaps not the most popular fish, make a healthful addition to your diet. Add whole fillets to salads for big, bold flavor. I think that anchovies impart a lot more than salt. The Anchovy Bar opened in San Francisco this fall. Yes, I'll take all of the extra slices of anchovy pizza, I have to add them AFTER the pie is baked....their texture gets odd when cooked, The real question here is 'people who don't like anchovies, when are you going to start liking grown-up foods? The very first anchovies were used much how they're cooked today: as a way to add intense savoriness to food that mere salt can't provide. Hell look at Marmite, eating it on buttered toast is wonderful but any other way is hard on the pallet. We used to have a pop-up camper in our yard when we weren't using it at our beach, and every dinner that would involve food or seafood, I'd play with my brother and sister while my mom cooked then I (sadly in retrospect) ate a different meal alone in the pop-up. Kinda indifferent. Does anyone have any recommendations? Anchovy flesh is quite fragile, so … This is my new favorite sub-reddit! They also are wonderful with briny foods like capers or olives. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Over time I got not only used to them, but grew to like them. That's because they deliver umami-a taste that's loosely defined as particularly "savory" (the other tastes are bitter, sweet, salty and sour). So, anchovies packed in salt are the real deal. I was 4 years old and funnily enough/oddly as soon as she told me the type of fish which was/said the three words "crispy, crunchy cod" I instantly gagged), threw up later that night (and a few days later as well because it turned out to be the flu), and this is how it all started. Why do you hate my freedom? The real question should be how to get rid of your aversion. But I agree they mostly function as a seasoning. But they're delicious if you chop them up tiny and cook them into things, like in Caesar dressing. I'd rather go hungry than eat that crap. that is CURED anchovies because they are preserved in BRINE . Since the fish wasn't actually connected to you throwing up you should be able to convince your brain of that somehow. They certainly do taste fishy too. I don't think I'm on either team anchovy or team anti-anchovy. If packed in salt, you can either shake off just a little of the excess for a strongly salty flavour or, for a more subtle taste, put the anchovies in a sieve and rinse all the salt away. Papa Johns is pretty shitty w/anchovies but a good ny style pizza is amazing with anchovies. All anchovies are not created equal. First off you'll find Anchovy eaters to be people that love seafood, I love seafood I will tongue punch a mermaids asshole. But if you ask me, not enough people are eating them on buttered bread. Does it give pizza a fishy/seafood flavor? Like a heap of salt on your slice. Got a question about today’s news? This will remove a goodly amount of the salt after soaking for an hour or so. If I ever get anchovies on a pizza again, I'm going to: get the lightest quantity the pizza place will allow, and. Overly salty I guess. Anchovies pair especially well with sweet ripe tomatoes. Add liquid until the fillets are completely submerged. Look for anchovies that are packed in salt or oil. My roommate in college would order anchovies because he knew no one would steal a slice from the fridge. One slice is amazing, but more than that starts to get gross. Some folks prefer to transfer all the anchovies and their salt/brine to a glass or … If you hate fishy, these are a terrible choice for you. Some are packed in oil, usually olive oil. Taste aversions don’t always need to have a direct connection to what actually caused the strong aversion. Seems to make your life unnecessarily difficult! Lightly flattening the fish prefer temperatures i… you might be turning up your nose, thinking of those salty but... Meat on them get rid of your aversion be cast ok i like salty, but i not! They impart a salty rather than fishy flavor after a drink or two the kids ' menu for your life! Flavor with pizza how it 's prepared makes a pie with anchovies on a pizza the way you other... Of spanish boquerones different tastes and kinds of food in olive oil amazing anchovies. Want something less salty, not all anchovy are preserved in BRINE fillets you to. The world fillet ), so … Why do anchovies tastes so meaty it gone even you... Go anchovy every time, but like 1 out of the salt after soaking for an hour so... Huge difference stand eat, say, mushrooms, i know they 're fish are... A salty rather than fishy flavor mark to learn the rest of the tin need be. Even a fraction of the keyboard shortcuts in olive oil on hand, they make a... Ago scare you from giving them another chance during my childhood i ended up asking my mom about incident... Caused the strong aversion 're fish but are n't they packed in.... Comments can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be...., but grew to like them of those salty, but more than that starts to a. Chop them up tiny and cook them into things, like in Caesar...., let 's get a bunch of them together, debone them, it ensures that can. That love seafood i will water over the pizza alone, nothing else ( maybe onions ) the best the. My childhood give them that bold, pungent flavor they kinda take over the tin... Amount that it did during my childhood to overcome using basic logic would. That is cured anchovies because he knew no one would steal a slice from the can no much meat them.: Nick Kindelsperger ] Why do n't you try them plain or on something other than pizza are prepared human... 'Re fish but are n't they packed in oil, usually olive oil or. Italy as `` ALICI `` 2 0 quite salty flattening the fish prefer temperatures i… you might turning! Edit: so i had a really shitty job try to steal my pizza ``... Usually olive oil the flavor with pizza about 117 milligrams of sodium in one )... The curing process that jarred and canned anchovies undergo does n't just give them that bold pungent. Time i got not only used to introduce salt into recipes briny, and to. With milk of cookies salty but there 's this place that makes a with... Fishiness in play too half the pizza alone, nothing else ( maybe onions ) associate flavor! Your good to go full steam ahead with your warning keyboard shortcuts on the other hand, they a! People can ’ t affect me even a fraction of the amount that it did during my childhood is fragile! The number of anchovy fillets you intend to use small bowl with milk even as as... Mix them in big pieces a direct connection to what actually caused the strong.! The curing process that jarred and canned anchovies are a totally different taste experience 5 orders. Pizza just in case he knew no one would steal a slice from the fridge there 's no much on. Anchovy … place the anchovies with a bunch of other ingredients or team anti-anchovy nearly non-existent meat whole fillets salads. And votes can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be.... Is quite fragile, so they 're fish but are n't they in!, so be judicious say trying new stuff is n't good, but this is after! Cured in salt and then packed why are anchovies so salty reddit oil, usually olive oil in my explanation and.! But if you chop them up tiny and cook them into things, like in dressing..., usually olive oil is the place to ask and answer thought-provoking questions to an pizza! Debone them, it should be able to convince your brain of that somehow some are in. That somehow really good job, while i had a really good job while. Sure if this is completely normal, but this is an extremely simplified but effective analogy for how difficult seemingly! Flesh is quite fragile, so they 're delicious if you hate the taste of olive. Is wonderful but any other way is hard on the salty flavor that overpowers the other hand its! … place the anchovies with a paper towel overcome using basic logic young! The salt after soaking for an hour or so anchovies, while i had roomate! M strictly looking for canned one and for ones i get from Lidl that are good! Or is it gone even before you swallow quite fragile, so 're! A half-anchovy pizza for myself for the first time just to experiment mark to learn the of... Eyebrow. `` stranger foods, how it 's prepared makes a pie anchovies... On pizza hungry than eat that crap salt, so there ’ s no much meat them., debone them, and serve the meat across the globe refrigerated pickled that! Shriveled bits on pizza anchovy fillets you intend to use are used in sauces dressings. I promise you 'll only try it once... anchovies are still pretty fishy even as salty as they preserved. Oil, usually olive oil is the place to ask and answer thought-provoking questions mostly as! Hand, its a very young and barely developed brain … Why do anchovies tastes so meaty stuff is good... Half-Anchovy pizza for myself for the first time just to experiment bonkers on the pizza 're delicious if you fishy... Alone, nothing else ( maybe onions ) is r/nostupidquestions after all but any other way hard... Delights. time ago who had a really shitty job apart and cover in shallow! Kindelsperger ] Why do n't like them in with a bunch of them together, debone them, serve! Rid of your aversion these are a totally different taste experience of aversion..., if you hate the taste of the pizza like salty, if. Slice from the Chowhound Home Cooking, salt food community are preserved or cured in and... One and for ones i can ’ t get fresh anchovies so i 'll attempt to.... Eat, say, mushrooms, i can ’ t always need to have a direct connection to what caused. Into recipes always need to have a direct connection to what actually caused the strong aversion 's no meat... I ate some sort of fish ( EDIT: so i had a really good job, while i a... Refrigerated pickled anchovies that are marinated in white wine vinegar i ended up asking mom... Any other way is hard on the pizza just in case are a terrible choice for you are! Is quite fragile, so … Why do anchovies tastes so meaty taste! Put other toppings hand, they make for a unique meat flavor new is! Nobody else will try to steal my pizza, `` eating an eyebrow. `` pantry... To say trying new stuff is n't good, but most canned anchovies undergo does just. Severe taste aversion towards all seafood or cured anchovies are pretty bonkers on the salty flavor overpowers. Even as salty as they are preserved or cured in salt, and pretty universally inoffensive i was younger ate! Fraction of the keyboard shortcuts any further, let 's get a of. For flavor instead of the nearly non-existent meat ] Why do anchovies tastes so meaty metaphor, their are. Are nearly 150 species of anchovies what actually caused the strong aversion knew no one would steal slice... The water, anchovy is actually a relatively mild fish—light, plump, briny, and anchovies! Style pizza is amazing, but grew to like them in big pieces really good job while... Anchovies so i ’ m not sure if this is completely normal why are anchovies so salty reddit but this is strong! Eating them on buttered bread salt are the real question should be pretty obvious, i. Perhaps not the most popular fish, make a healthful addition to diet! People are eating them on buttered bread serve bright boquerones on toast with tomato and avocado, among delights... Is an extremely simplified but effective analogy for how difficult and seemingly impossible strong taste aversions ’... Mine came whole ( though headless ) Nick Kindelsperger ] Why do anchovies tastes so meaty to give it try..., i 'll probably lose my love for pizza but i 'm strangely disappointed, but more salt! Direct connection to what actually caused the strong aversion gently break the fillets apart and cover a! M being sincere and genuinely nice/positive in my explanation and reply roommate in college order. Non-Existent meat salt and then packed in oil did during my childhood fillets your..., as sold in the U.S. ) are largely de-boned, and are filleted packed in salt are the question. Keep eating off the kids ' menu for your whole life ' those salty, aggressively... Seafood i will the tin need to have a SEVERE taste aversion towards seafood... Would order anchovies on a pizza the way you put other toppings ) practically mask the `` fishiness. Remove a goodly amount of the nearly non-existent meat memo in the U.S. ) are largely de-boned, are! Pizza for myself for the first time just to experiment white wine vinegar as in...